"These two brands price closer than most comparisons suggest — the gap is largely a payment-terms difference, not a rate difference. What actually separates them is booking flexibility, a loyalty bypass, and which counter you're walking up to."
Put a Hertz quote and an Enterprise quote side by side on an aggregator and Hertz often looks dramatically cheaper. That gap is real — but it's not a price difference. It's a payment-terms difference. Hertz offers a pay-now option that discounts the rate by 30–35% in exchange for locking in early. Enterprise's standard model for US bookings is pay at counter, with no equivalent rate discount for prepaying. Strip that variable out and both brands come in within a few dollars of each other at major US airports.
That's the most useful thing to know before comparing them. The Hertz review and Enterprise review cover each brand in full — what follows is what changes when you put them side by side.
How they compare at a glance
| Category | Hertz | Enterprise |
|---|---|---|
| Price — LAX Midsize SUV, Jul 2026 (pay later) | $112 total | $116 total |
| Pay-now discount option | Yes — $73 at LAX (35% saving vs pay-later) | No discount rate — US bookings are pay at counter by default; prepayment available but without a price reduction |
| Additional driver fee | $15/day; waived for AAA members | Varies by location — typically lower than Hertz |
| Counter bypass (loyalty) | Yes — Gold Plus members skip the counter at Hertz-owned airports | No — Enterprise Plus base tier is points-only; no bypass at standard level |
| US locations | ~2,500 — mostly airports | ~4,600 — airports plus neighbourhood branches |
| Insurance presentation | Bundled tiers online: $34–$50/day (roadside included) | Itemised: DW up to $40.99 + Roadside $6.99 + SLP $12.95 separately |
Compare car rental prices
Compare Hertz, Enterprise, and every other option at your airport — prices and location scores alongside each other.
Affiliate link
The price question
At LAX in July 2026, a Midsize SUV for one day came to $112.28 at Hertz and $115.54 at Enterprise — both on pay-later terms, both the same vehicle class. A $3.26 difference. The brands are at parity.
Hertz's pay-now rate for the same booking was $73.16 — a genuine $39 saving against their own pay-later price. That discount is real and it compounds on longer rentals. The catch is commitment: Hertz pay-now bookings cancel free within 24 hours of booking, then fees apply. Enterprise allows prepayment in the US but doesn't discount for it — their standard model is pay at counter, with free cancellation up to pickup. The saving Hertz offers in exchange for commitment isn't available at Enterprise for US bookings.
What this means in practice: if you're comparing quotes on an aggregator and Hertz is showing a dramatically lower rate, check whether you're looking at Hertz's pay-now price against Enterprise's pay-later price. That comparison is almost always what produces the headline gap — and it's not an apples-to-apples read.
Renting in Europe? The picture is different. Enterprise offers a pay-now discount of up to 15% in the UK, Ireland, Spain, France and Germany — which means both brands offer comparable early-booking flexibility outside the US. Compare both on pay-now terms at your specific European airport before deciding.
Insurance at the counter
Both brands offer optional damage coverage — but they present it differently, and that difference matters at the desk.
Hertz bundles its coverage into three tiers online: Basic Protection ($34.43/day), Standard Protection ($45.47/day), and Complete Protection ($49.57/day). Roadside assistance is included in all three. The online rates carry a discount over the counter price — so the decision is worth making before you arrive, not under time pressure at the desk.
Enterprise itemises its protection products separately: Damage Waiver (up to $40.99/day), Roadside Protection ($6.99/day), and Supplemental Liability Protection ($12.95/day). Taking all three approaches Hertz's Complete Protection price, but you can mix and match. The itemised structure is more transparent — you're paying for exactly what you choose — but it requires more decisions at the counter.
Either way, the first question to answer before you reach either brand's desk is whether your credit card already covers rental collision. Most major travel cards do, when you pay with the card and decline the counter insurance. That makes the conversation at either brand's counter simple. Knowing your answer in advance is the preparation that matters.
Loyalty programs
The programs work differently enough that the right one depends on how often you rent and where.
Hertz Gold Plus Rewards delivers its headline benefit from the base tier: at Hertz-owned airports, Gold members go directly to the lot, choose their vehicle, and leave without queuing. On a busy travel day that's a 20 to 40 minute difference. The limitation is the expiry window — points lapse after 12 months of inactivity, which makes Gold Plus poorly suited to travellers who rent a few times a year and forget to keep the account active. AAA members get an additional benefit: the young driver surcharge and additional driver fee are both waived, which on a week-long family rental can exceed the annual AAA cost.
Enterprise Plus is simpler and more forgiving. Points accumulate per rental with no blackout dates on redemption, and the expiry window is three years rather than twelve months. The tradeoff is that the base tier doesn't include a counter bypass — you queue with everyone else. Enterprise's structural advantage is its neighbourhood network: if you're renting near home rather than at an airport, Enterprise almost always has a branch closer to you, and many locations offer pickup from your address.
Neither program delivers the seamless skip-the-counter experience of National's Emerald Club, which is available from the first rental without tier requirements. Our Hertz vs Avis comparison covers how Gold Plus stacks up against Avis Preferred, and the rental car loyalty programs guide maps the full market.
Which one should you book?
Price is the priority and you're flying into a major airport. Compare both on pay-later terms at your specific airport — that's the fair read. If Enterprise comes in lower, book it. If they're within a few dollars, check the DiscoverCars score at your pickup location and go with whichever scores higher.
You want to lock in the rate early. Hertz. The pay-now option saves 30–35% against pay-later and isn't available at Enterprise for US bookings. If your plans are firm and you're comfortable with the 24-hour cancellation window, it's a genuine saving worth taking.
You're renting near home, away from a major airport, or need pickup from your address. Enterprise. With ~4,600 US locations versus Hertz's ~2,500 — mostly concentrated at airports — Enterprise almost always has a branch closer to you, and many locations offer pickup from your address.
You rent frequently and the counter is the friction point. Neither brand offers a true counter bypass at base loyalty tier — for that, National's Emerald Club is the comparison that matters. See our National vs Enterprise comparison for how the Emerald Aisle stacks up against what both Hertz Gold Plus and Enterprise Plus actually deliver.
How airport scores compare
The overall DiscoverCars scores — Hertz 8.4, Enterprise 8.4 — are identical at the aggregate level, which makes them useless as a tiebreaker. What the aggregate hides is how differently the two brands perform by market. The same brand that leads in California looks different in Spain, and the airport you're actually standing in is where the decision plays out. The scores below come from DiscoverCars and cover verified rentals at each location.
| Airport | Hertz | Enterprise | Best pick |
|---|---|---|---|
| Barcelona (BCN) Spain | 7.8 | 7.4 | Hertz |
| Fort Lauderdale (FLL) Florida | 8.6 | 9.0 | Enterprise |
| Dublin (DUB) Ireland | 8.5 | 9.0 | Enterprise |
| Amsterdam (AMS) Netherlands | 9.0 | 8.7 | Hertz |
| Faro (FAO) Portugal | 8.5 | 9.2 | Enterprise |
DiscoverCars scores by airport. Only locations where both brands have sufficient verified review volume are included. Source: DiscoverCars, accessed July 2026.
Enterprise leads clearly in California — LAX and SFO are two of the highest-scoring locations of any major supplier in the US, and they pull the statewide figure up significantly. Hertz leads in Amsterdam and edges Barcelona. Ireland and Portugal both go to Enterprise by a meaningful margin. Florida is close enough that price should decide.
Picking up at LAX specifically? The Hertz LAX review covers the pickup process, surcharge stack, and what to expect at that location in full.
The verdict
If you haven't booked yet: Start with the pay-later price at your specific airport — that's the fair comparison. If Hertz's pay-now rate works for your schedule and you're comfortable locking in early, it's a genuine saving worth taking. If your plans are uncertain or you're renting away from a major airport, Enterprise's flexibility and neighbourhood reach give it the structural edge. Check the DiscoverCars score at your pickup location for both brands before committing — the gap at some airports is meaningful.
If you're already booked: Sort your insurance before you arrive — your credit card may cover rental collision, or it may not. Either way, knowing your answer means the counter conversation is a confirmation, not a decision. At pickup, photograph the car fully before you drive off. For Hertz: if you're in a toll state, make your PlatePass decision before you reach the desk, and don't open the transponder box if you're using your own. For Enterprise: the protection products are three separate line items — know which you need before the agent asks.
If you've already returned the car and have a question about a charge: If you booked through a third-party platform, start there — they have direct leverage. Then contact the brand in writing with your rental agreement and photos. For Hertz, PlatePass charges dispute directly with PlatePass, not Hertz customer service. Give it one week. If it doesn't move, a credit card chargeback with your documentation is the next step.
Compare car rental prices
Compare Hertz, Enterprise, and every other supplier at your airport — prices and location scores alongside each other before you commit.
265,000+ verified reviews · 1,000+ brands · Free cancellation
Affiliate link - we may earn a commission
- Comparing Hertz pay-now rates against Enterprise pay-later rates on an aggregator makes the gap look far larger than it is — check both on equivalent payment terms before deciding.
- Hertz pay-now cancellation: free within 24 hours of booking, then fees apply. Enterprise pay-later cancels free up to pickup — if your plans might change, that flexibility has real value.
- Hertz Gold Plus bypass only works at Hertz-operated locations — not at franchise airports. Confirm your airport's status before counting on it.
- Enterprise's insurance is itemised at the counter — Damage Waiver, Roadside Protection, and SLP are three separate line items. Know which you need before you arrive.
- Post-return damage claims are the most consistently reported complaint pattern at both brands. Photograph the car at pickup — exterior, interior, timestamp included.
- Additional driver fees vary by Enterprise location. Confirm the daily amount in your booking before arrival.
Frequently asked questions
Is Hertz or Enterprise cheaper?
On pay-later terms — the only fair basis for comparing the two — they come in within a few dollars of each other at major US airports. The gap that appears on aggregators is usually a payment-terms difference: Hertz offers a pay-now rate that can be 30–35% cheaper than its own pay-later price. Enterprise allows prepayment in the US but without a discounted rate — their standard model is pay at counter. Compare both on pay-later terms at your specific airport before deciding.
I'm flying into LAX — which should I book?
Enterprise scores 9.4 on DiscoverCars at LAX across 108 reviews — one of the highest scores of any major supplier at that airport. Hertz's LAX score isn't yet available on DiscoverCars with sufficient review volume to include here. On pay-later terms the price gap is under $5. If you want to lock in your rate early, Hertz's pay-now option saves around $40 at LAX compared to pay-later. If you're flexible on payment timing, check both scores directly at your airport on DiscoverCars before committing.
I already booked — what should I do before pickup?
Sort your insurance before you arrive — your credit card may cover rental collision, or it may not. Either way, knowing in advance means the counter conversation is a confirmation, not a decision under pressure. At pickup, photograph the car fully before you drive off — exterior, interior, timestamp automatic on your phone. For Hertz: if you're on a toll-heavy route, decide on PlatePass before you reach the desk, and don't open the transponder box if you're using your own. For Enterprise: the insurance products are itemised separately — Damage Waiver, Roadside, and SLP are three different line items. Know which you need before the agent asks.
Which loyalty program is worth joining?
Hertz Gold Plus Rewards is worth joining if you rent at major Hertz-operated airports — the counter bypass is real and free to access from the base tier. Points expire after 12 months of inactivity, which makes it poorly suited to occasional renters. Enterprise Plus is simpler: points accumulate per rental, redeem with no blackout dates, and expire only after three years without activity. Neither program delivers the same skip-the-counter benefit as National's Emerald Club — see our National vs Enterprise comparison or our rental car loyalty programs guide for how they stack up across the full market.
Hertz or Enterprise charged me after I returned the car — what are my options?
If you booked through a third-party platform, raise it there first — they have direct leverage with the supplier. Then contact the brand in writing with your rental agreement, pickup photos, and return photos. For Hertz: PlatePass charges dispute directly with PlatePass, not Hertz customer service. Give it one week. If it doesn't move, a credit card chargeback with your documentation is the next step.
Does it matter which brand I book if the price is the same?
Yes — the location score at your specific airport matters more than the brand average. Both brands have strong airports and weaker ones. Enterprise leads clearly in California and most of Western Europe; Hertz leads in Amsterdam and edges Spain. Florida is close enough that price should decide. Check the DiscoverCars score for your pickup location before committing — a 0.5 point difference in score reflects a meaningfully different average experience at that counter.
